Thayers

The witch hazel toner sitting in carts today is a single survivor from a catalog that once ran to roughly eight hundred preparations. Dr. Henry Thayer, trained in chemistry at a Boston medical school, built his 19th-century apothecary around concentrated 'fluid extracts' of medicinal plants, and by the 1870s he was publishing a thick descriptive catalogue of tinctures, infusions, syrups, poultices, and wines. His extracts earned period accolades, including a silver medal from the American Institute of New York in the 1850s, and the operation reportedly supplied remedies to physicians during the American Civil War.

Witch hazel was only one entry on that long list, described in old company literature as a tonic and astringent for checking discharges, but it outlasted nearly everything around it. For generations the company was also known for medicinal lozenges, including slippery elm, sold across drugstore counters, and the brand spent much of the 20th century as a low-key natural-remedies name rather than a beauty label.

Its modern relevance turns on one formulation choice. By offering an alcohol-free version of a category most people associated with stinging, drying liquids, the brand quietly repositioned witch hazel as gentle rather than harsh, which is precisely the trait that later endeared it to skincare beginners with short, recognizable ingredient lists. The witch hazel itself is now grown on a family farm in Fairfield County, Connecticut, and the line leans into certified-organic, vegan sourcing.

The enduring caveat is botanical, not historical: witch hazel's astringent and soothing effects are real but mild, and a toner remains an optional step rather than a treatment. What the long backstory explains is the brand's character, an apothecary's surviving heirloom rebuilt for a modern shelf, valued for gentleness, accessibility, and remarkable longevity rather than for cutting-edge actives.

Sources:[1][2][3]